About
The Letter

LAMiamiNY

Remodel

Inside a Heat Pump Change-Out

A dealer's change-out list, the load calculation, the line set, the panel and commissioning show who installs a heat pump, what they check and what it costs.

Inside a Heat Pump Change-Out. Smiling HVAC technician with arms crossed and colorful gauge hoses around the neck, standing in front of a green ivy wall.
Photo: waketechcc, CC0 1.0, via Flickr

Clint Newsome is a heat pump dealer, and when he describes a change-out he talks like someone reading a work order. In his account on Carrier's cost page, the crew tests the refrigerant lines already in the wall, sets a new pad outside, fits a new drain pan with a safety switch, makes new duct connections, and finishes with filters and a thermostat.

The drain pan is the item nobody sees again. Its switch is there so a clogged drain stops the system before water finds a ceiling. Most of the trade works like that: the parts that matter are the ones you stop noticing.

Newsome's list is the middle of the day. Before the pad goes down, someone has done the arithmetic.

The load calculation

Richard Trethewey of This Old House advises that installers run a Manual J load calculation and not size the system by rule of thumb or by whatever the house had before. A house changes: a system picked for a drafty place can be wrong once the envelope is tighter.

The technician also reads what is already there. The Building America Solution Center says equipment past 15 years can be assumed near the end of its life, and its table lists 15 years for an air-to-air heat pump and 30 for ductwork. The ducts may outlast the machine, so they get inspected, not assumed.

The line set

Testing the refrigerant lines comes first on Newsome's list for a practical reason. This Old House says replacements that reuse existing ductwork, electrical service and refrigerant lines cost less than installs needing new ducts, electrical upgrades or structural changes. The line set is often where a simple swap becomes a bigger job.

It is also where certification matters. BLS notes that technicians must follow refrigerant conservation, recovery and recycling rules, and ServiceTitan reports that federal rules require EPA Section 608 certification for technicians servicing equipment that could release refrigerants.

The electrician and the panel

A heat pump runs on electricity, so the house's service has to carry it. Carrier, which sells heat pumps, says older homes may need electrical upgrades or ductwork repairs, and both add to the price. Panel work is the electrician's trade, not the HVAC technician's, so a change-out on an older house can mean two crews on the calendar.

Who does the work

BLS reports that 68% of HVAC mechanics and installers worked for plumbing, heating and air-conditioning contractors. The usual path is a postsecondary nondegree award and long on-the-job training, sometimes with a license. NATE-certified technicians can service or install equipment including heat pumps.

Commissioning

A system is not finished when it turns on. The Building America Solution Center recommends ENERGY STAR commissioning checklists covering refrigerant charge, indoor fan airflow and air balancing. It also warns that a tighter envelope can reduce natural ventilation, which may call for added ventilation and a combustion safety check.

A cold-climate job in New York

New York is where the cold-climate question comes up most. NYS Clean Heat says cold-climate air source and geothermal heat pumps can each supply "up to 100% of a building's heating and cooling" needs, and it offers homeowners a Buyer's Guide and a planner quiz. EnergySage says most homeowners probably will not need backup heat, though some keep an old furnace or boiler.

What it costs and what to ask

Published prices differ because houses do. This Old House's 2026 survey of 1,000 homeowners put the average installation at $8,042, and 58% of those who replaced a system paid $150 or more an hour for labor. Carrier, a manufacturer, estimated in 2026 that installed units run $6,000 to $25,000. EnergySage reported whole-home installs averaged about $19,000 in 2025, roughly $16,500 once state and local credits and rebates were counted.

Savings are reported separately. A 2024 NLR (formerly NREL) study found a median of $300 to $650 a year saved by households moving from electric, fuel oil or propane heat, and EnergySage cites a 2024 study where 95% of cold-climate households saw lower bills. Those are medians and shares, not a promise for one house.

To ask an installer: is a Manual J in the quote, who holds Section 608 certification, do the ducts, line set and panel need work, and how will the system be commissioned?

The last item on the list

EnergySage says cold-climate heat pumps use variable speed operation, running continuously and ramping up and down instead of cycling on and off. On Clint Newsome's list, the pad, the drain pan and the duct connections all come first. The last thing the crew sets is the thermostat.

Highlights

Who installs a heat pump?

HVAC technicians, most often employed by plumbing, heating and air-conditioning contractors. Federal rules require EPA Section 608 certification for those servicing equipment that could release refrigerants.

What does a heat pump cost?

This Old House's 2026 survey put the average installation at $8,042, while Carrier estimated $6,000 to $25,000 installed in 2026. EnergySage reported whole-home installs averaged about $19,000 in 2025.

What does the technician check?

A Manual J load calculation first, then the existing ducts, refrigerant lines and electrical capacity, and at commissioning the refrigerant charge and airflow.

More Stories

From LA Miami NY

A cabana daybed beside a rooftop infinity pool high above a curving bay, beaches and a city skyline
The Letter

Each new story from LA Miami NY, sent to your inbox when it is published. Nothing else. Leave any time.