About
The Letter

LAMiamiNY

Real Estate

Roof, Wiring, Pipes and Foundation Pricing for an Older House

Which trades to price first on an older house, how to compare their bids, and how much contingency to hold, from the roofer's remaining-life estimate to the structural engineer's verdict.

Fixer-Upper Roof Wiring Pipes Pricing. Slate roof of a brick building with a wooden ladder resting on the slope and scaffolding at the edge, seen from a railed walkway.
Photo: Jaggery, CC BY-SA 2.0, via Wikimedia Commons

A roofer standing at the eave of an older house isn't there to patch anything. The job, as Opendoor's guide describes it, is a remaining-life estimate: how long before this roof becomes your problem. A roof with years left is a line you can defer. One near the end goes into the opening budget, before anyone has picked a paint color. That is the order for the whole house: ask the trades whose answers move the offer first, and let the cosmetic things wait, because they never move it.

Steps From Walkthrough to Offer

Paint is the one part of an old house that confesses its flaws out loud. The systems behind it keep quiet, so the first walkthrough should go to them.

  1. Walk it once for the big systems, not the finishes. Broker Christine Dupont-Patz said to make sure electrical, HVAC and plumbing are sound or budgeted for, since ugly paint is easy to fix and electrical updates are not.
  2. Write a scope of work. The Resident guide advises a clear written scope before you request quotes, so bids can be compared accurately.
  3. Book the specialists during the inspection stage, before you buy. Chase calls quotes gathered at that point essential.
  4. Collect itemized written estimates covering materials and labor, as NAR's consumer site advises.
  5. Add permits, relocation if you need it, and a contingency.
  6. Compare the total with a comparable move-in ready home, then set the offer.

Which Trades to Call First

The full bench, per MortgageResearch, is a roofer, structural engineer, electrician, plumber and HVAC technician, with a sewer-scope provider or environmental professional added when the house calls for one. Opendoor ranks structural, roofing, plumbing, electrical and HVAC problems as costlier than wallpaper and dated tile. Northwestern Mutual's advice is to bring trusted contractors in before the offer, with a roofer or structural engineer added if needed.

Foundation and Structural Costs

The structural engineer's call is the one that can end a deal. Chase warns that a house with significant structural damage can cost more to repair than it is worth, and says to watch for foundation cracks and severe mold or water damage. Angi puts a foundation repair at an average of $5,000 and a replacement at $20,000 to $100,000, and advises a structural engineer plus written estimates. Serious structural work has to be done before move-in, Northwestern Mutual notes, which may mean carrying two properties financially.

Electrical and Plumbing Pricing

Opendoor sends wiring questions to a licensed electrician. Block Renovation says pre-war buildings may hide lead paint, ancient wiring or old plumbing, and that bringing them up to code isn't optional. Angi notes that plumbing or electrical work often requires permits, and permits on large projects could cost $400 to $2,500 and up. Put that line in the budget before the bids arrive.

HVAC and Water Heater Age

In a September 2026 MortgageResearch article, Charles Goodwin of Kiavi recommends focusing on the big-ticket items: heating and cooling equipment, electrical panels and water heaters. ENERGY STAR suggests considering replacement when an AC or heat pump is over 10 years old, or a furnace or boiler is over 15 years old. The labels are readable at the first walkthrough, so read them.

How Many Contractor Bids to Get

Nobody publishes a magic number, but the advice is consistent: more than one bid per trade. Block Renovation adds not to simply pick the cheapest. Bolster wants each quote to cover materials, labor and potential contingencies, and broker LeAnne Carswell advised getting several bids. Goodwin suggests reviewing contractor costs line by line before you offer, which only works if every bid answers the same written scope.

Contingency Table for Older Houses

No source splits contingency by house age, so here is what each recommends. The age reading is ours: the older the house, the nearer the top of the range.

| Source | Contingency |
|---|---|
| Chase (experienced renovators) | an additional 10-20% of the budget |
| Block Renovation (NYC guide, March 19, 2025) | typically 10-20% of total budget |
| Opendoor (moderate whole-home work, April 2026) | 10-20% buffer |
| Broker LeAnne Carswell | at least 20% |

The case for the high end is easy to see once a wall is open. Bolster says opening walls can reveal "structural damage, electrical or plumbing issues, or mold and asbestos". In August 2023 it said owners typically underestimate the true cost of a renovation by as much as 20 to 40 percent.

Turning Bids Into an Offer Number

Bolster advises counting the square feet actually being renovated, not the home's total footprint. Opendoor's test is that a fixer-upper is likely sound if purchase price plus renovation plus contingency lands at least 10-15% below a comparable move-in ready home. Angi puts temporary relocation during larger renovations at $2,000 to $10,000 or more, a line to add if you can't live there during the work. Bolster also suggests asking the seller about HVAC, electrical and the roof, and whether past additions were illegal or not up to code.

By the end of the walkthrough the paint will still be ugly. Dupont-Patz's point stands: that is the part you can fix on a weekend. The panel, the pipes and the roof are what the bids will be about.

Highlights

Which contractors should I call first on an older house?

Start with the structural engineer, roofer, electrician, plumber and HVAC technician, since those problems cost more than cosmetic ones. Get their quotes during the inspection stage, before you buy.

How much contingency should I hold on a fixer-upper?

Chase, Block Renovation and Opendoor point to 10-20%, and broker LeAnne Carswell advised at least 20%. Bolster says owners can underestimate true cost by as much as 20 to 40 percent.

How many bids do I need?

The sources say multiple, without a fixed number. Make each bid itemized for materials and labor, and compare them line by line.

More Stories

From LA Miami NY

A cabana daybed beside a rooftop infinity pool high above a curving bay, beaches and a city skyline
The Letter

Each new story from LA Miami NY, sent to your inbox when it is published. Nothing else. Leave any time.