About
The Letter

LAMiamiNY

Real Estate

What a Contractor Checks in a Fixer Upper Before You Offer

Ask every contractor what worries them most, walk the six stops in order, then price each finding line by line so the offer carries the repairs.

Ask the contractor one question before anyone opens a door: what worries you most about this house? A lender on BiggerPockets suggested exactly that, and the answer shows where your due diligence money should go. It matters because a remodeling team quoted by Redfin said hidden wiring, plumbing and water damage rarely show in an ordinary walkthrough. The person who builds and opens walls for a living is the one who knows where to look.

Who to Bring to a Fixer Upper Showing

Start with a general contractor who can give you a usable scope before your contingencies expire, which is how Mortgage Research describes an owner-occupant's team. Depending on the house, the same article says a roofer, structural engineer, electrician, plumber, HVAC technician or sewer-scope provider may also be needed. The home inspector's report is a separate job, and Chase says it helps you start estimating costs. The contractor's visit is the one that starts the pricing.

What a Contractor Checks in a Fixer Upper

Walk the same six stops in the same order every time, so nothing gets skipped when the talk wanders. They follow the major systems on Redfin's list: foundation and framing, roof, electrical, plumbing and sewer lines, and HVAC. At each stop, ask the question, then write the answer down in the contractor's own words.

  1. Electrical panel. Ask whether this panel can carry the house as it is or needs replacing. Panels are among the big-ticket items Kiavi's Charles Goodwin tells buyers to focus on.
  2. Water heater and shutoff. Find the main shutoff, then ask how old the heater is and what the pipes behind it are made of. Inspector Nick Thruston flags polybutylene piping, common in 1980s and 1990s homes.
  3. Attic. Ask what they see overhead: wiring, staining, anything that points to a past leak. This is where the hidden problems Redfin's remodelers mention tend to sit.
  4. Crawlspace. Ask about moisture, termite damage and old plumbing. A Redfin-quoted buyer in Atlanta called those common in Georgia, and said septic systems on older or rural properties should be inspected too.
  5. Roof. Ask for a plain verdict, repair or replace, and whether a roofer should come back for a closer look.
  6. Foundation. Go last, because it can end the deal. Chase warns that foundation cracks and severe mold or water damage can cost more time and money to fix than the house is worth.

Patches That Point to a Past Problem

Look for repairs that cover only one spot. A BiggerPockets commenter said fresh drywall in one place, new flooring in one room, or paint on only the lower part of a basement wall usually signals a problem to investigate before you price anything. Then ask what realtor Ametria Chaney asks: was the past work permitted?

How to Price a Repair List Line by Line

Chaney posted that she prefers line-by-line scopes to a lump sum, and Goodwin also recommends reviewing contractor costs line by line before an offer. Rocket Lawyer says the lowest estimate is not always the right one, and that bids that seem too low to be true deserve wariness. Some contractors cannot price accurately without opening walls, so Rocket Lawyer says you can ask for worst-case estimates or negotiate the seller's permission for a more thorough look. Base the numbers on code-compliant work.

Example of Pricing Repairs Into an Offer

Take the example in Redfin's guide and carry it through. A $250,000 home needs $60,000 of repairs. Redfin recommends a 10% to 20% contingency, and here it uses 15%, which is $9,000. Add them up and the house costs about $319,000 before closing and financing costs.

That $319,000 is the number to test. Chase suggests asking whether the home, once repaired, would be comparable in value to renovated properties nearby. Chaney says the offer should leave room for the purchase, the renovation, contingency, holding costs and a risk margin, all based on the after-repair value. If the total lands above what renovated neighbors are worth, the repair list is your reason to offer less.

Order the work as Redfin does: safety, structure, water damage and essential systems first, since cosmetic projects can often wait.

Permits Can Add Work to the Offer

Ask whether the planned work needs permits, and put the scope and change pricing in writing, as Chaney advises. Chase also says to look ahead for permits or regulations that could affect the plan. A Denver general contractor quoted by Redfin explained why: pulling a permit for one room can require bringing other parts of the house up to code, such as smoke and CO alarms. Buyers, the contractor said, should budget for that before buying.

Highlights

Who should I bring to a fixer upper showing?

A general contractor who can give a usable scope. Depending on the house, a roofer, structural engineer, electrician, plumber, HVAC technician or sewer-scope provider may also be needed.

What should I ask the contractor first?

Ask what worries them most about the house. A BiggerPockets lender commenter said the answer can show where to spend due diligence money.

How much contingency should I add to the repair list?

Redfin recommends a 10% to 20% renovation contingency. Its example adds 15% ($9,000) to $60,000 of repairs on a $250,000 home, about $319,000 before closing and financing costs.

More Stories

From LA Miami NY

A cabana daybed beside a rooftop infinity pool high above a curving bay, beaches and a city skyline
The Letter

Each new story from LA Miami NY, sent to your inbox when it is published. Nothing else. Leave any time.