About
The Letter

LAMiamiNY

Design

Architect or Interior Designer Who to Hire First

The order of hand-offs on a room, from the architect's five phases to the interior designer, the contractor and the trades who build it.

Architect or Interior Designer First. Black and white photo of a bespectacled architect in a suit and tie pointing at a large site plan drawing pinned on the wall beside him.
Photo: Seattle Municipal Archives from Seattle, WA, CC BY 2.0, via Wikimedia Commons

Ask for the drawing set before you ask for a price. The New York studio Havard Cooper, which designs apartment renovations in the city, advises engaging the architect before signing a contractor agreement, because hiring a builder before the construction documents are complete can be risky. A contractor pricing a half-finished drawing is pricing a guess, and the guess comes back as change orders.

Who to Hire First

For most remodels the answer is the architect. IMK Architects says to start with the architect, who defines layout, structure and design direction first. The exception is a renovation without structural changes, or an interior-only upgrade, where the firm says starting with an interior designer makes sense.

The split in the work is simple. Houzz says interior designers focus on the look and use of interiors, while architects design the structure of a building inside and out, and that a license is required to be an architect in the US but not to be an interior designer. In New York, the title to look for is explained in Hiring a Certified Interior Designer for a New York Co-op.

Why the Order Matters in Los Angeles, Miami and New York

Havard Cooper's studio says about 80% of the work happens in the design phases, before a contractor has a complete drawing set. That is where money is saved or lost, so a wrong order is expensive. It is also where the city gets its say: AIA says schematic design is the research phase, when zoning and jurisdictional restrictions are found and addressed, and Havard Cooper's New York process puts permits ahead of contractor bidding. Whether the job is in Los Angeles, Miami or New York, the local rules are found by whoever draws first.

Each city has its designers too. Interior Designers in Miami and How to Hire One shows what light and salt air ask of a room, and in Los Angeles, Michael Rasky says to visit a finished room before hiring anyone.

Architect Phases From Schematic Design to Construction

The AIA B101-2017 agreement, as Monograph describes it, defines five phases. Pre-design and programming come before them under a separate scope. In order:

  1. Schematic Design. The architect consults the owner on goals and requirements. The aim is a client signature on the basic plan before any detailing.
  2. Design Development. Mechanical, electrical, plumbing, structural and architectural details are laid out, with the owner and the structural and MEP engineers involved. It often ends with a formal presentation and owner approval.
  3. Construction Documents. Owner approval is required before this phase begins. The result is the drawing set a contractor can price.
  4. Procurement. The 2017 edition renamed Bidding or Negotiation to this. The owner, with the architect's help, evaluates bids, and the deliverable is a construction contract.
  5. Construction Phase. The architect helps the contractor build what the owner-approved documents specify, with contract administration running until the final certificate of payment.

When the Interior Designer Joins

The hand-off here is an overlap. IMK Architects says the interior designer comes in once structure and layout are largely defined, typically during design development. Houzz says designers typically contribute toward the end of a project, fitting their concept to the architect's plan, and Designing Buildings says the two collaborate from the early stages to set goals and a design concept.

The designer's work includes sourcing and ordering materials, furnishings and decor, according to Houzz. What designers are choosing now is in Built-In Shelves and Curbless Showers Designers Are Using Now. When a question turns architectural, such as removing a wall, Houzz says the designer needs to consult a contractor or architect for safety.

Contractors and Trades After the Drawings

The builder takes the baton at procurement. Havard Cooper's studio issues the construction documents, walks the site with bidders and levels the bids before the client hires a contractor, then oversees construction. The trades named in the design development phase, mechanical, electrical and plumbing, are the ones whose layouts are drawn before anyone arrives with tools, so each crew works from the same set. For a built-in, that set includes shop drawings, and Millwork Shop Drawings Checklist for a New York Built-In shows what they have to say before a board is cut.

Architect vs Interior Designer Fees

Monograph gives rule-of-thumb fee shares by phase: schematic design 10%, design development 25%, construction documents 40%, procurement 5% and the construction phase 20%. Havard Cooper says it charges about 10 to 15% of construction cost for full architectural and interior design. The architect's side of the bill, phase by phase, is in Architect Fees for a House. Under standard AIA agreements the owner furnishes the written program, and an architect who writes it does so as a supplemental service for a separate fee.

Havard Cooper's process for a New York apartment ends on neither a drawing nor a permit. After consultation, design, bidding and construction oversight, the last step on its list is final installation and styling.

Every Design Guide, One Page Each

Highlights

Who comes first, the architect or the interior designer?

Usually the architect, who defines layout, structure and design direction first, according to IMK Architects. The interior designer typically joins during design development, unless the job is interior-only with no structural changes.

What are the architect's five phases?

Schematic Design, Design Development, Construction Documents, Procurement and the Construction Phase, as defined in the AIA B101-2017 agreement.

When should I hire a contractor?

After the construction documents are complete. Havard Cooper advises engaging the architect first, since hiring a builder before then can be risky.

More Stories

From LA Miami NY

A cabana daybed beside a rooftop infinity pool high above a curving bay, beaches and a city skyline
The Letter

Each new story from LA Miami NY, sent to your inbox when it is published. Nothing else. Leave any time.