Garage Door and Roof Projects Before Listing
A $4,672 garage door returned $12,507 at resale, and a major kitchen returned about half its cost. A checklist of which pre-listing projects pay back and which trade does each.

The line that should reorder your list sits in the 2025 Cost vs. Value report: a garage door replacement cost $4,672 and returned $12,507 at resale, a 268% recoup. A midrange major kitchen remodel cost $82,793 and returned $42,130. The cheap job beat the showpiece room by a wide margin, so decide before you hire anyone:
- Call a broker and ask which projects buyers in your neighborhood expect to see finished.
- Book a pre-listing walk-through and get the findings in writing, room by room.
- Take only that short list to the trades, and compare each quote with the recoup figure for the same project below.
The figures come from the NAR/NARI 2025 Remodeling Impact Report and Cost vs. Value. They describe national averages, not your house.
Remodel to Sell or Remodel to Live In
Ask yourself which one you are doing. Consumers in the NAR report gave reasons ranging from worn-out surfaces to wanting a change to preparing to sell, and those goals lead to different projects.
Also ask who is doing the math. NAR sets the resale value Realtors estimate a project adds against costs estimated by NARI members. Cost vs. Value compares average costs with resale value across U.S. markets. When the two disagree, your broker can say which one matches your block.
Painting Before Listing Which Rooms
Paint is the project agents name most. Half of Realtors recommended painting the entire home before listing, and 41% recommended painting a single interior room. NAR REALTOR News summed up the advice as paint first and make sure the roof is in shape. The two reports used here give no painting cost, so the walk-through list is where a painter's quote starts.
Roof Replacement Cost and Return
New roofing was the third most recommended pre-listing project, at 37% of Realtors, and they reported a 43% rise in demand for it. In Cost vs. Value, an asphalt shingle roof replacement cost $31,871 and recouped 68%. Metal roofing cost $51,865 and recouped 50%. Roofers quote both, so ask for both prices.
Kitchen and Bath Remodel Return on Investment
Kitchens draw the most interest: Realtors reported the biggest rise in demand for a kitchen upgrade (48%), with bathroom renovation at 35%. Scale decides the return. A midrange minor kitchen remodel recouped 113%. According to Amarr's summary of the report, that job meant new cabinet fronts, fresh hardware and a modern cooktop and oven range. The midrange major remodel recouped 51% and the upscale version 36%.
Baths follow the same pattern: a midrange bath remodel recouped 80% and an upscale one 42%.
Window Replacement Return on Investment
Vinyl window replacement recouped 76% in Cost vs. Value and wood window replacement 70%. Real estate professionals told NAR that window replacements, storage solutions and space-adding improvements that leave the footprint alone tend to bring returns that are decent but not full.
Deck, Stone Veneer and Siding Return
Wood deck additions recouped 95% and composite decks 89%. Manufactured stone veneer cost $11,702, returned $24,328 and recouped 208%. Fiber-cement siding recouped 114%. A backup generator recouped 95%, while solar power installation recouped 30%.
Additions and Basement Remodels Return on Investment
Large additions recouped the least in Cost vs. Value: a midrange primary suite addition 32%, an upscale one 18% and an ADU 41%. A basement remodel cost $52,012 and recouped 71%. A primary suite can still be a fine project to live in, since the NAR report gave it a top Joy Score, but the resale figures point the other way.
Garage Door and Steel Entry Door Return on Investment
Steel entry door replacement cost $2,435, returned $5,270 and recouped 216%. NARI members, working from their own estimates, put a new steel front door at 100% cost recovery, a new fiberglass one at 80% and closet renovation at 83%. Amarr, a door maker, noted in its blog that nine of the top ten Cost vs. Value projects were exterior improvements, with the garage door, steel entry door and stone veneer on top.
Amarr's blog also relays a view from Zonda Advisory's Todd Tomalak: the existing-home market has shifted to favor move-up buyers, and a new garage or entry door can make a house stand out.
Highlights
Which pre-listing projects do agents recommend most?
Painting the whole home came first, with half of Realtors recommending it. Painting one interior room (41%) and new roofing (37%) followed.
Which projects recouped the most in Cost vs. Value?
Garage door replacement recouped 268%, steel entry door replacement 216% and manufactured stone veneer 208%.
Is a big kitchen remodel worth it before selling?
Usually less than a small one. A midrange major kitchen remodel recouped 51% in Cost vs. Value, while a midrange minor remodel recouped 113%.
