What a Home Appraiser Measures and Checks
An appraiser counts only finished above-grade space, then sets a value from comparable sales and adjustments. Here is what to hand over before the visit and what is left to the inspector.

The appraiser is the only guest who will measure your finished basement, write it down, and then leave it out of the size. That matters because when an appraised value comes in under the negotiated price, a buyer with an appraisal contingency can adjust the contract to the new number, so the sale price is back on the table. No appraiser requires a form from you, but a page left on the kitchen counter, built from how the numbers work, can save a long conversation:
- List the upgrades and repairs you have made, since HomeLight says appraisers weigh condition, repairs and upgrades.
- Mark which finished spaces are below grade, such as a walk-out basement, because those are not counted in the size figure.
- Mark any finished space reachable only from outside the main house, including an accessory dwelling unit, which is also left out.
- Add the square footage from your listing or public records, so any gap between that and the appraiser's number can be explained.
The appraiser is one of the hands behind every sale, and the one who works for the lender, not for the buyer or the seller. This piece is a spoke of From Listing to Keys, Everyone in a Home Sale, and it explains why each line on that page matters.
What an Appraiser Does on Site
A licensed appraiser sets the value, not the lender, the buyer or the seller. The lender orders the appraisal, the borrower typically pays, and most appraisals cost $325 to $1,000, according to Kiplinger.
Inside and out, the appraiser evaluates condition, size and layout. HomeLight's list of what gets weighed runs from age, bedrooms and baths to foundation, basement, attic and HVAC. Then the appraiser looks past your lot line for power lines, noise, steep hills and changes in traffic. Kiplinger says the visit can "take as little as 30 minutes or as long as a few hours", while Zillow puts the typical appointment at about an hour, with the report following in about a week.
What Counts as Square Footage
This is where the big-house question gets answered. The standard residential report says gross living area, not square footage, and lending agencies agree that means finished, above-grade residential space. Partly or fully below-grade areas are out. So are garages, porches, patios, and finished areas you cannot reach from inside the main dwelling.
Except in new construction with plans, the appraiser measures the property, using the outside dimensions of each floor for one-unit homes. That part of the job has been changing: Fannie Mae now requires the ANSI standard, and under it a floor with soil against any exterior wall counts as below grade, with the two kinds of space reported separately.
That is why numbers disagree. The NC Real Estate Commission gave the example of an appraisal showing 2,400 sq ft above grade against a 3,000 sq ft listing, explained by 600 sq ft of below-grade living area. When the appraiser's figure differs from public records, the report has to say why.
How Comps and Adjustments Set the Value
Appraisers use three approaches: sales comparison, cost, and income, the last generally for multiunit dwellings. For a typical house, sales comparison does most of the work, setting your home beside similar, nearby, recently sold properties drawn from sales data, MLS and county records. The cost approach adds the site's value to the estimated cost of replacing the dwelling, less depreciation.
Zillow says appraisers look for at least three similar homes sold within 90 days, and admit that is not always possible. An agent told HomeLight that comps generally sit within a mile and six months, with the net widened for unusual properties.
Then come adjustments. Each comp's sale price is the starting point, and the appraiser adds or subtracts for what differs from your home. Freddie Mac requires those changes in dollars, with the basis for every one explained. Paired sales can isolate what the market pays for a single feature, such as an end unit versus an interior townhouse. On the report, comps sit in columns, and a net adjustment total shows how far the appraiser moved from the raw prices.
What the Home Inspector Checks Instead
An appraiser tells you what a home is worth; an inspector tells you what is right or wrong with it, in HomeLight's phrasing. An inspection examines the roof, foundation, electrical, plumbing, HVAC, doors, windows and appliances to find problems. An appraisal estimates market value.
The appraiser does not recommend or detail repairs. An inspector does, and may point to specialized inspections too. So the dripping valve or the aging panel is the inspector's find, while the appraiser weighs condition only as it bears on value.
What Happens After the Walk-Through
By Zillow's account, the appraiser walks the interior and exterior, drives the neighborhood, then researches recent comparable sales and public records before writing the report. So the last thing your house sees of its appraiser is a car rolling slowly past the power lines, noise and traffic that bear on value, and the next thing is a page of comps in columns, each adjusted until it stands beside yours.
Highlights
What counts as square footage to an appraiser
Appraisers report gross living area, which is finished, above-grade residential space. Below-grade areas, garages, porches, patios and finished areas not reachable from inside the main dwelling are excluded.
How does an appraiser turn comps into a number
They start from the sale prices of similar nearby recent sales, then add or subtract dollar adjustments for differences from your home. Freddie Mac requires an explanation of the basis for all adjustments.
Does the appraiser check the roof and plumbing like an inspector
No. An inspector examines systems like the roof, electrical, plumbing and HVAC to find problems and recommends fixes, while an appraiser estimates market value and does not recommend repairs.
Sources
- Why Do Square Footage Disputes Arise?
- NCREC Bulletins – NCREC Residential Square Footage Guidelines vs. ANSI Standard
- What Happens During a Home Appraisal? | Kiplinger
- What Does an Appraiser Do to Determine Home Value?
- Home Appraisal: What It Is and How It Works | Zillow
- Sales Comparison Approach in Appraisals | Homebuyer.com
